Course contents
Practitioner · Course 1: How Retail Makes Money · Lesson 3 of 5

Why a retailer plans open-to-buy before it plans a single style

Level: FoundationTime: 45 minutesOrder used: A (the T-shirt, an equivalent-value domestic reorder lot for Cedar & Co.)Tool: Retail profitability worksheet
For a domestic retail buyer or planner who must set a spending budget before choosing any single style. You need lesson T19-C01-L01. Figures are teaching examples in US dollars.
RetailerCedar & Co., 12 shops, Make to Stock
Domestic orderEquivalent-value reorder lot from Delta Garments, own forecast
Season budgetUSD 120,000 committed spend limit, illustrative for this lesson
Committed spend before this styleUSD 96,000 already committed to other styles this season
BuyerOmar, owner of Cedar & Co.
What this lesson measuresHow much open-to-buy remains before Cedar & Co. commits to any single style
02Opening

This page explains why a retailer sets a spending budget before it chooses any single style to buy

This page is for a domestic retail buyer or planner who has to explain why a retailer decides how much it can spend for a whole season before it decides what to spend that money on. At work, a buyer who has not planned a season budget in advance can commit to a style that looks attractive on its own, only to discover there is no money left for a better style later in the season. This lesson mainly teaches the money flow: it shows how a retailer's open-to-buy, its season budget minus what it has already committed, decides whether a new style can be bought at all, before the style's own margin is even considered.

Cedar & Co., a local domestic brand with 12 shops that buys from Delta Garments on 60-day open account, sets a season budget of USD 120,000 for a category of T-shirts equivalent in value to Order A. Omar, the owner, has already committed USD 96,000 of that budget to earlier styles this season. Without this skill, a buyer approves a new style purely because its own margin looks good, without first checking whether the season budget has any open-to-buy left to spend on it.

03Before you start

What you need, and what this lesson does not cover

You need: lesson T19-C01-L01, which shows how a retailer's own margin is calculated against its own shop price.

By the end of this lesson you can:

  • define open-to-buy as a season budget minus committed spend;
  • calculate how much open-to-buy Cedar & Co. has left before approving a new style;
  • explain why open-to-buy is checked before a style's own margin, not after;
  • state what happens when a buyer commits spend beyond the remaining open-to-buy;
  • avoid approving a new style purely on the strength of its own margin.

Not covered here: the cost of stock that does not sell at full price (lesson T19-C01-L04) and combining open-to-buy with margin and markdown in one worksheet (lesson T19-C01-L05).

04Key terms

Words you will meet in this lesson

TermMeaning
Open-to-buyA retailer's season budget minus its committed spend: the amount still available to commit to any range.
Committed spendThe value of purchase orders a retailer has already confirmed against its season budget.
MarginProfit divided by the selling price, shown as a percentage of what a company sells for.
ReorderA repeat purchase order placed against a style the retailer has already sold before, based on its own forecast rather than a new buyer commitment.
Wholesale priceThe price a brand charges when it sells the finished goods on, for example to its own retail arm or another retailer.
Consignment stockStock a supplier keeps ownership of while it is physically held at the factory, until the factory uses it.
05Teaching
The rule

Open-to-buy, not a single style's own margin, decides whether a retailer can commit to it at all

A retailer that plans by Make to Stock sets a season budget for what it expects to spend on a category, then subtracts every purchase order it has already committed to reach its own open-to-buy: the amount still free to commit. A new style's own margin only matters once open-to-buy confirms there is room to spend on it at all; a style with an excellent margin cannot be bought if the season budget is already spent. This ordering, check the money available before judging the style, is what protects a retailer from running out of budget partway through a season.

Cedar & Co.'s own open-to-buy before this style: 120,000 - 96,000 = USD 24,000
What you meet in real life

A retailer's open-to-buy behaves differently depending on how the business buys and how the season is timed

A buyer meets several shapes of open-to-buy across a normal working year, and checking it correctly in each one prevents an attractive style from being approved with no budget actually behind it.

What can differThe shapes you will meetWhy it matters
Make to Stock domestic buying against a forecastCedar & Co. commits its own season budget against its own sales forecast, before any final customer has bought anything.The forecast itself, not only the committed spend, can turn out wrong, so open-to-buy must be reviewed as actual sales come in, not only set once at the season's start.
Make to Order export buying against a confirmed buyerNorthline Apparel commits spend to Delta Garments only once its own retail customer, such as Fairway Stores, has placed a confirmed order.Open-to-buy still applies, but the commitment follows a confirmed sale rather than a forecast, which lowers the risk of committing spend that never sells.
A reorder placed on a style that already sold wellCedar & Co. reorders a T-shirt style equivalent to Order A once it sells faster than forecast in its shops.A reorder still draws down open-to-buy exactly like a new style; strong early sales do not create extra budget on their own.
A season budget reallocated between categoriesOmar reallocates open-to-buy that was set aside for one style to a different, better-performing style instead.Reallocation changes which style gets the remaining open-to-buy, but it never creates new open-to-buy beyond the original season budget.
The case we follow

Omar reviews a new T-shirt style equivalent to Order A against Cedar & Co.'s own remaining open-to-buy

Cedar & Co. set a season budget of USD 120,000 for its T-shirt category and has already committed USD 96,000 across earlier styles. A supplier proposes a new style, priced equivalent to Order A's own retail chain (a landed cost equivalent to USD 3.70 per piece, wholesale USD 8.00, and a strong projected margin), that would need a purchase order of USD 30,000 to buy the quantity Omar wants. Omar likes the style's own margin, but has to check the season budget before approving anything.

Cedar & Co.: season budget compared with committed spend and the new style's own costCommitted spend, USD 96,00024,000 openNew style needs 30,000
The new style's own USD 30,000 cost is larger than Cedar & Co.'s remaining USD 24,000 open-to-buy. The style cannot be approved in full without either reducing its own quantity or reallocating budget from another style.
The worked number

Cedar & Co.'s own open-to-buy is not enough to cover the new style's full quantity without a change

Cedar & Co.'s own season budget: USD 120,000
Cedar & Co.'s own committed spend so far: USD 96,000
Cedar & Co.'s own open-to-buy remaining: 120,000 - 96,000 = USD 24,000
Shortfall against the new style's own USD 30,000 cost: 30,000 - 24,000 = USD 6,000

The new style is short by USD 6,000 against Cedar & Co.'s own remaining open-to-buy. Omar cannot approve the full quantity without either reducing the order, reallocating open-to-buy from a weaker style already committed, or asking for a season budget increase, none of which the style's own attractive margin can fix on its own.

The method

Four steps a domestic retail buyer follows before approving any new style

  1. State the season's total budget for the relevant category, agreed before the season starts.
  2. Total every purchase order already committed against that budget, including reorders already placed.
  3. Subtract committed spend from the season budget to find open-to-buy, updating the figure each time a new order is confirmed.
  4. Compare the new style's own required spend against that remaining open-to-buy before considering its margin.
  5. Record the decision, whether approved in full, reduced, or reallocated from another style, so the next review starts from the correct remaining figure.
The trap

A common mistake is approving a new style because its own margin looks strong, without first checking open-to-buy

A common mistake is judging a new style purely by its own attractive margin and approving it before checking whether the season budget has any open-to-buy left. A style with a 59.8% margin, equivalent to Fairway Stores' own figure on Order A, is still unaffordable if the season's committed spend has already used up the budget. What this costs a retailer that gets it wrong is real: approving styles in the order they are proposed, rather than against the remaining open-to-buy, can leave a retailer overcommitted mid-season, forced to cut a later, possibly better-margin style entirely because an earlier, weaker style already used the budget it needed.

Two approval orders compared against Cedar & Co.'s own USD 120,000 season budgetBy margin alone: style approved, budget checked afterOver by 6,000By open-to-buy first: style resized to fit remaining budgetFits within 24,000 open
Checking open-to-buy first keeps the new style's own cost inside the season budget. Approving by margin alone risks committing USD 6,000 beyond what the budget actually has left.
06In plain words

A retailer plans how much it can spend before it decides what to spend it on. The season budget is the total available; committed spend is what has already been promised to suppliers; open-to-buy is the difference between the two, the money still free to commit. A new style's own margin only matters once open-to-buy confirms there is room to buy it at all. A retailer that checks a style's margin first and its budget second can end up promising more money than it actually has left, forcing a cut to a later style instead.

07Quick check
  • Open-to-buy is a season budget minus committed spend.
  • A new style's own required spend is checked against open-to-buy before its own margin is judged.
  • A reorder draws down open-to-buy exactly the same way a brand-new style does.
  • Reallocating open-to-buy moves it between styles but never creates budget beyond the original season total.
  • A Make to Stock retailer's open-to-buy depends on its own forecast, which can itself turn out wrong.
  • Approving styles purely in the order proposed, instead of against remaining open-to-buy, risks overcommitting the season budget.
08Workplace scenario

Omar must decide whether to approve a new T-shirt style at its full proposed quantity

Cedar & Co.'s season budget for its T-shirt category is USD 120,000, with USD 96,000 already committed. A supplier proposes a new style, equivalent in value to Order A's own chain, requiring USD 30,000 to buy at the quantity proposed. The style's own projected margin is 59.8%, equivalent to Fairway Stores' own figure. Omar has one week to respond before the supplier's own production slot is offered elsewhere.

Here is the note Omar actually wrote to his own buying team:

New style review. Season budget: USD 120,000. Committed spend to date: USD 96,000. New style cost at proposed quantity: USD 30,000. New style's own projected margin: 59.8%. Decision needed within one week.

Can Omar approve the new style at its full proposed quantity? Decide before opening the answer.

Show decision

No, not at the full proposed quantity. Two figures in Omar's own note decide this.

First, Cedar & Co.'s own open-to-buy is USD 24,000. That is the season budget of USD 120,000 minus the committed spend of USD 96,000, and it is USD 6,000 short of the new style's own USD 30,000 cost.

Second, the style's own 59.8% margin does not change the budget available. A strong margin makes a style worth buying if there is room in the budget; it cannot create USD 6,000 of open-to-buy that does not exist.

Omar's options are to reduce the new style's own quantity to fit within the USD 24,000 open-to-buy, to reallocate committed spend away from a weaker earlier style, or to request a season budget increase before the supplier's deadline. Approving the full quantity without one of those three steps would overcommit the season budget by USD 6,000.

09What it costs

What overcommitting the season budget costs Cedar & Co.

Using this lesson's own illustrative figures:

Cedar & Co.'s own remaining open-to-buy: USD 24,000
New style's own required spend: USD 30,000
Amount the season budget would be overcommitted by, if approved in full: 30,000 - 24,000 = USD 6,000

An overcommitment of USD 6,000 against a USD 120,000 season budget is a 5% overrun, small enough to seem manageable on one style alone, but a retailer that repeats this mistake across several styles in the same season can overcommit its total budget by a much larger amount, forcing rushed cuts to later, potentially better-margin styles once the shortfall is discovered.

10Working template

Retail profitability worksheet: track season budget, committed spend and open-to-buy before approving any style

Open the course workbook's "Open-to-buy" sheet. It lists the season budget, every committed purchase order, and calculates remaining open-to-buy automatically. Enter a new style's own required spend to see immediately whether it fits inside the remaining open-to-buy, before its own margin is even reviewed.

[Download the Retail profitability worksheet](../../templates/T19-C01-retail-profitability-worksheet.xlsx)

Download the Retail profitability worksheet (Excel)

11Check yourself

1. What does open-to-buy measure?

2. A retailer has a season budget of USD 50,000 and has committed USD 42,000. A new style needs USD 5,000. Can it be approved from open-to-buy alone?

12Glossary
ENARFRTRMeaning
Open-to-buyالرصيد المتاح للشراءBudget disponible (open-to-buy)Alıma açık bütçe (open-to-buy)A retailer's season budget minus its committed spend: the amount still available to commit to any range.
Committed spendالإنفاق الملتزم بهDépenses engagéesTaahhüt edilen harcamaThe value of purchase orders a retailer has already confirmed against its season budget.
MarginالهامشMargeMarjProfit divided by the selling price, shown as a percentage of what a company sells for.
Reorderإعادة الطلبRéassort (réapprovisionnement)Yeniden siparişA repeat purchase order placed against a style the retailer has already sold before, based on its own forecast rather than a new buyer commitment.
Wholesale priceسعر الجملةPrix de grosToptan fiyatThe price a brand charges when it sells the finished goods on, for example to its own retail arm or another retailer.
Consignment stockمخزون أمانةStock en dépôtKonsinye stokStock a supplier keeps ownership of while it is physically held at the factory, until the factory uses it.
13Next

Lesson 1.4: Markdown, promotion and the real cost of unsold stock

You now know a retailer sets a spending limit before choosing any style. The next lesson moves to what happens when stock bought inside that budget still fails to sell at full price. Back to the course map

14Ladder

RecognizeTell open-to-buy apart from a single style's own margin.
ConnectSee how committed spend reduces a season budget down to its remaining open-to-buy.
CompareWeigh a new style's own required spend against remaining open-to-buy before its own margin.
DecideJudge whether a new style can be approved in full, reduced, or delayed against the season budget.