Course contents
Practitioner · Course 2: RFQ and Supplier Quotation Comparison · Lesson 1 of 5

What a request for quotation (RFQ) must specify for a fair comparison

Level: PractitionerTime: 45 minutesOrder used: A (the T-shirt)Tool: Quotation comparison sheet
This lesson is for anyone who sends or receives a request for quotation: a buyer's merchandiser, a factory's own merchandiser, or a sourcing agent. T13-C01 (Supplier Sourcing and Qualification) is the prerequisite; it covers finding and qualifying a supplier before this lesson's document is ever sent. Money figures are teaching examples in US dollars.
BuyerNorthline Apparel (overseas clothing brand)
Candidate factoryDelta Garments (garment factory)
ProductBasic cotton T-shirt, one colour
Quantity15,000 pieces
Target FOBUSD 3.20 per piece
DocumentRequest for quotation (RFQ)
02Opening

This page teaches what a request for quotation must state before any supplier's answer can be compared fairly, for anyone who writes or reads this document

A request for quotation, RFQ for short, is the document a buyer or a merchandiser sends to one or more suppliers asking for a price and terms on a named style. A merchandiser at a buying office uses this document every time a new style needs a price from more than one factory. Without a complete RFQ, each supplier fills the gaps with its own assumption: one prices a smaller trial quantity, another prices a different delivery point, and the two answers that come back are not answers to the same question at all. This lesson mainly teaches the information flow: what facts a buyer must put in writing before asking a factory to quote.

03Before you start

What you need, and what this lesson does not cover

You need: the supplier-qualification steps from T13-C01, and the FOB and delivery-terms vocabulary from T01-C01 and T01-C05.

By the end of this lesson you can:

  • list the six facts a fair RFQ must state;
  • explain why an RFQ without a target delivery date produces quotes that cannot be timed against each other;
  • explain why the same style must be described identically to every supplier asked to quote it;
  • recognise an RFQ missing a required fact before it is sent.

Not covered here: why two complete quotes still differ once they arrive (lesson 2.2), adjusting quotes to a common basis (lesson 2.3), weighing price against lead time and quality (lesson 2.4), and building a full comparison sheet (lesson 2.5).

04Key terms

Words you will meet in this lesson

TermMeaning
Request for quotation (RFQ)The document a buyer sends a supplier asking for a price and terms on a named style, quantity and delivery.
QuotationA supplier's written answer to an RFQ, stating its price and the terms that price is based on.
Delivery termsThe point named in a purchase order where delivery happens, such as FOB at a named port, and the date it is due.
Payment termsThe part of a purchase order stating when and how the factory is paid, for example letter of credit at shipment or open account.
FOB (free on board)The factory delivers the goods on board the ship at its own port. Freight from there is the buyer's cost.
Target delivery dateThe date the buyer needs the goods to reach the agreed delivery point, stated in the RFQ before any supplier quotes.
05Teaching
The rule

An RFQ is fair only when it states the same style, quantity, delivery terms, payment terms and target date to every supplier asked to quote it

A supplier cannot price what it has not been told. A request for quotation that leaves out a fact forces every supplier who receives it to guess that fact for itself, and different suppliers guess differently. A fair RFQ removes the guessing by stating six facts in writing: the style (with its own specification), the quantity, the fabric or material specification, the delivery terms (FOB, CIF or EXW, with the named point), the payment terms, and the target delivery date. Once all six are fixed and identical across every supplier asked, the quotations that come back answer the same question, and a price difference between them means something real.

Order A's RFQ facts, all six fixed once: style T-shirt, quantity 15,000 pieces, fabric single jersey 180 GSM Ne 30/1, delivery FOB Alexandria, payment letter of credit at shipment, target date week 16
What you meet in real life

How much an RFQ states, and how it is sent, varies by buyer, by product and by how the relationship with the supplier already stands

What can differThe shapes you will meetWhy it matters to you
How the specification is attachedA buying office like Northline Apparel's attaches a full tech pack and fabric spec to the RFQ. A smaller domestic brand may describe the style in one paragraph and a sample garment.A style described only in words, with no attached spec, is read differently by each supplier; a fair comparison needs the same written spec sent to all.
Which delivery terms are asked forAn export buyer usually asks for an FOB quote, since it arranges its own onward shipping. A domestic brand buying ex-factory, such as Cedar & Co., asks for an ex-factory or delivered price instead, since there is no port hand-over.Asking two suppliers for different delivery terms on the same style produces two quotes that cannot be compared until one is converted to match the other (lesson 2.3).
How many suppliers receive the same RFQA buyer may send one RFQ to a single qualified supplier it already trusts, or to three or four suppliers at once for a genuine comparison.Comparison only has meaning once at least two suppliers answer the identical document; one quote alone has nothing to be checked against.
Whether a target date or only a lead time is asked forSome RFQs state a fixed target delivery date the goods must reach by. Others ask each supplier to state its own lead time and let the buyer work out the resulting date.A target date lets the buyer compare offered lead times against one shared deadline; asking only for lead time still needs a starting point (the order confirmation date) before it becomes a real date.
The case we follow

Sara at Northline Apparel writes the RFQ for the T-shirt order before sending it to two qualified factories

Sara, the buyer at Northline Apparel, has qualified two factories through the T13-C01 process, including Delta Garments. Before asking either one to quote Order A, she writes one RFQ document and sends the identical version to both.

RFQ factWhat Sara states
StyleBasic cotton T-shirt, one colour, tech pack attached
Quantity15,000 pieces, size ratio S:M:L:XL 1:2:2:1
Fabric/specSingle jersey 180 GSM, Ne 30/1 combed cotton
Delivery termsFOB, named port of loading, Alexandria
Payment termsLetter of credit at shipment
Target delivery dateWeek 16 from order confirmation
The worked number

The same 15,000-piece quantity, priced with two different delivery terms, cannot be read as two comparable numbers until converted to one basis

Delta Garments' FOB quote: 3.20 USD per piece
A second factory's ex-factory quote (no shipping/duty added): 2.95 USD per piece
Difference as printed: 3.20 - 2.95 = 0.25 USD per piece, but this comparison is not yet valid (lesson 2.3 shows the conversion)
Same style, two delivery termsDelta Garments: FOB 3.20Includes port hand-overFactory Y: ex-factory 2.95No shipping to port included
A lower printed number on different delivery terms is not a lower real price. The two figures answer different questions until converted to the same basis.
The method

Write a fair RFQ in five steps

  1. State the style with its full specification, attached, not summarised in one line.
  2. Fix the quantity, including any size or colour breakdown.
  3. Name the delivery terms and the exact point (FOB port, CIF port, or EXW factory).
  4. State the payment terms the buyer expects to offer.
  5. Set a target delivery date, or the date the lead time counts from if a lead time is asked for instead.
The trap

A common mistake is sending the same style description to every supplier but leaving delivery terms or target date to each factory's own default

A merchandiser under time pressure often copies the style specification carefully but leaves the commercial lines, delivery terms, payment terms, target date, blank, assuming every factory will quote "the normal way." Factories do not share one normal way: one assumes FOB, another assumes ex-factory; one assumes the buyer's usual 60-day terms, another assumes cash before shipment. The quotes that return then differ for reasons that have nothing to do with which factory is more competitive, and the buyer wastes a review cycle discovering this only after the numbers are in. The fix costs nothing more than filling in the same six lines every single time, on a template the buyer reuses for every style, rather than trusting memory on a document written under deadline pressure.

RFQ silent on termsRFQ states all six factsFactory A assumes FOB, 60-dayterms. Factory B assumes ex-factory, cash before shipment.Both factories quote FOB,60-day terms, against thesame target date.
A silent RFQ produces quotes that answer different questions. Stating all six facts once removes the guessing that makes two quotations incomparable.
06In plain words

A request for quotation is the document that asks a factory for a price. It only works if it says exactly what is being priced: which style, how many pieces, what fabric, delivered where and how, paid for when, and needed by when. If any of these is left out, each factory fills the gap in its own way, and the prices that come back are not really prices for the same thing. Writing all six facts once, and sending the identical document to every factory asked, is what makes the answers worth comparing at all.

07Quick check
  • A fair RFQ states style, quantity, fabric/spec, delivery terms, payment terms and target delivery date.
  • The same written specification must go to every supplier asked to quote, not a summary to one and a full pack to another.
  • Delivery terms (FOB, CIF, EXW) must be named with the exact point, not assumed.
  • A target delivery date lets lead times be compared against one shared deadline.
  • A lower quoted price on different delivery terms is not yet a lower real price.
  • Comparison only has meaning once at least two suppliers answer the identical RFQ.
08Workplace scenario

Sara sends Order A's RFQ to a third factory but forgets to state the delivery terms

Sara wants a third opinion on Order A's price and sends the RFQ to a new factory quickly, reusing the style specification but forgetting to copy the delivery-terms and payment-terms lines from the template. The new factory returns a quote of USD 2.90 per piece with no note on what that price includes.

Here is the quotation Sara receives:

New factory's quotation, Order A. Style: basic cotton T-shirt. Quantity: 15,000 pieces. Price: 2.90 USD per piece. Delivery terms stated: none. Payment terms stated: none.

Can Sara compare this USD 2.90 figure directly against Delta Garments' FOB 3.20? Decide before opening the answer.

Show decision

No, she cannot, yet. Two facts decide this.

First, an unstated delivery term is not the same as FOB. Without delivery terms written into the RFQ, the new factory has quoted on its own default basis, most likely ex-factory, which does not include moving the goods to the port. Comparing 2.90 against Delta Garments' FOB 3.20 as if both included the same hand-over would be comparing two different things.

Second, the gap was Sara's own RFQ, not the factory's answer. The new factory answered the document it was sent; since that document never named delivery terms, the factory is not at fault for defaulting to its own normal practice.

Sara must go back to the new factory and ask it to re-quote on the same FOB terms stated to Delta Garments, before either number can be placed in the comparison sheet.

09What it costs

An incomplete RFQ costs a full quotation cycle, not just an inconvenience

Framed qualitatively, every fact missing from an RFQ that has to be chased afterward costs one extra round trip with the supplier, typically several days given time zones and factory workload, before a comparable number exists at all. On a 16-week timeline, a delay at the quotation stage eats directly into the weeks the buyer has left for approvals and fabric booking.

A three-day delay to re-quote, out of 16 weeks (112 days) total: 3 / 112 = 0.027, about 3% of the whole timeline lost to one missing RFQ line

Writing the six facts once, into a template reused for every RFQ, removes this cost entirely.

10Working template

Quotation comparison sheet: start with the RFQ tab that lists the six facts every quotation must answer

Open the Quotation comparison sheet workbook linked below. Its "RFQ facts" tab lists the six facts this lesson teaches, with Order A's own facts filled in as the example. Fill in the yellow "Your order" column with the same six facts for your own style before sending your own RFQ to any supplier.

[Download the Quotation comparison sheet](../../templates/T13-C02-quotation-comparison-sheet.xlsx)

Download the Quotation comparison sheet (Excel)

11Check yourself

1. Which six facts must a fair RFQ state to every supplier asked to quote the same style?

2. A buyer sends the same style specification to two factories but does not name delivery terms in either RFQ. What is most likely to happen?

3. A domestic brand buying 3,000 pieces ex-factory sends an RFQ with a target delivery date but no stated payment terms. Why is this still incomplete?

12Glossary
ENARFRTRMeaning
Request for quotation (RFQ)طلب عرض سعر (RFQ)Demande de devis (RFQ)Teklif talebi (RFQ)The document a buyer sends a supplier asking for a price and terms on a named style, quantity and delivery.
Quotationعرض السعرDevisTeklif (fiyat teklifi)A supplier's written answer to an RFQ, stating its price and the terms that price is based on.
Delivery termsشروط التسليمConditions de livraisonTeslimat şartlarıThe point named in a purchase order where delivery happens, such as FOB at a named port, and the date it is due.
Payment termsشروط الدفعConditions de paiementÖdeme şartlarıThe part of a purchase order stating when and how the factory is paid, for example letter of credit at shipment or open account.
FOB (free on board)تسليم على ظهر السفينة في ميناء المصنعFOB (franco à bord)FOB (gemide teslim)The factory delivers the goods on board the ship at its own port. Freight from there is the buyer's cost.
Target delivery dateتاريخ التسليم المستهدفDate de livraison cibleHedef teslim tarihiThe date the buyer needs the goods to reach the agreed delivery point, stated in the RFQ before any supplier quotes.
13Next

Lesson 2.2: Why two supplier quotes for the same style are rarely comparable as received

You now know what a request for quotation must specify. The next lesson shows what happens when a buyer sends a complete RFQ to two factories and still receives two quotes that cannot be placed side by side without more work. Back to the course map

14Ladder

RecognizeName the six facts a fair RFQ must state.
ConnectSee why an RFQ missing delivery or payment terms lets each supplier default differently.
CompareTell an RFQ ready to send from one still missing a required fact.
DecideJudge whether a quotation received can be compared yet, or must be sent back for a missing basis.